Checking in
I went out for a drink with two lovely acquaintances last night, and afterwards, although it was super late, decided in my buzzed and tiramisu’d state to head over to Sweet, Smart Scientist’s house. I called him on the way down his street, and while he sounded reluctant to see me (because he was tired, he said), I persuaded him to let me up for a few minutes. Which of course turned into three hours.
I really wasn’t going to bring up the state of the relationship, but he sort of seemed to expect a reason for my semi-forced entry (I’m so good with passive aggressive persuasion techniques; for instance, saying “So you’re saying I should turn around and walk home?” and then responding to his “Well, I don’t want to say that!” with “Great, I’ll be at your house in 2 minutes”), so although I was prepared to leave after my pre-stated 5 minutes, I sat down again with him.
"You seemed kind of upset last night when you got out of the car," he observed.
"I was really tired," I said, which was true. "And ... I have some things on my mind that are kind of stressing me out, things that I need to decide soon."
"What are they?"
"I don't really want to talk about them now. And... I kind of feel like I should check in with you and see how you're feeling about ... stuff."
He still feels the same way, since the intractable problem still exists. So he explained that, and I took it in and then I said:
“I’m confused about the sex.”
“Well, sex is something that happens between a man and a woman, and it’s for procreation purposes…“
“I’m confused when the man tells the woman he doesn’t want to have sex with her because he needs to get clarity on certain things, and the woman says okay, and then they have sex anyway.”
“It wasn’t a matter of me not wanting to have sex with you. It was more a matter of whether I could resist my desire to have it so that I could get some clarity.”
“So, did you get clarity?”
“Yes, I think so.”
“And what’s clearer now?”
“I think – I guess I came to the realization that I can’t imagine this going anywhere. I can’t imagine this as a long term thing. And if I were advising a friend who was in my position, I would say that he should end it, because it's not a healthy situation.”
Wow. Okay. That’s new. I sat dumbly for a minute.
A bit later, we had this exchange:
“This isn’t a unilateral thing, you know. I mean – what do you want? Do you want to have a sexual relationship?”
“Um -- yes.”
“Do you want it to be monogamous?”
“Yes.”
“Do you want us to date exclusively?”
“Yes.”
“The thing is, I can’t commit to – I feel like I’m not letting myself be in a situation where I could find someone who has more long term potential –“
“Oh. Okay. So, I’m preventing you from finding –“
“It’s not you, it’s me deciding to see you –“
“Fine. So your deciding to see me is preventing you from finding a wife. Life partner. Soulmate. Whatever.”
“You’re oversimplifying things.”
“No, I don’t think I am. It’s a logical progression. You want a relationship with long term potential, and you don’t think this is it. You want to make healthy choices for yourself, and you don’t think this is healthy. So… why are you doing this?”
“Because I really like you. But I’m not – I don’t think I can give you what you want.”
“How do you know what I want?”
“Because you just said you wanted an exclusive relationship.”
“Okay, wait a second. You’re – I think we’re operating on different definitions here. You asked me if I wanted an exclusive relationship and I said yes, because I think if I knew you were dating other people, I would feel hurt.”
“I think I would feel hurt too, if I knew you were dating other people.”
“So, okay. Normally? When two people feel that way? It usually means that they feel a connection, and enough of a connection to date exclusively. Which, you know, is kind of the definition of monogamy.”
“Are you sure you didn’t do debate in high school?” (He was on the debate team in high school.)
“It’s just not a great place to be – knowing that I’m the unhealthy choice.”
“That’s not really –“
“Yeah, okay, so it’s your choosing to see me that’s the unhealthy choice. That sounds to me like I’m the unhealthy choice.”
Pause. He took both my hands in his.
“Can’t you see that the reason I’m having such a hard time with this is because you’re wonderful and sweet and funny and brilliant and attractive?”
Aaaaaand … my insides sort of turned into a gooey mess. “Thank you. For saying that.”
“It’s just what I feel.”
So what do I do with this? It was a serious conversation, but it was also punctuated by laughter and jokes about getting married and caresses on the cheek and touching my hair and holding hands. But get this – he asks me: “So what does this mean?”
“Well,” I said slowly, “I think for you it means that you’re trying to be healthy about your romantic life, and you know you should break things off, but you don’t want to face the immediate hurt, so you’re putting it off. And for me, it means that I don’t know what’s going to happen, but I’m open to anything, including a long-distance thing, if we decide to do that. And if it doesn’t work out, then it means that I at least was pretty happy for four months.
“But – can you do me a favor? If you are going to break things off, can you please wait until after May 7, or preferably after May 18? ‘Cause I really need to concentrate on finals. No, seriously.”
He laughed, I laughed, and after that, we didn’t do much talking. And two hours later, I turned down his offer of a ride and walked back to my dorm in the cool-ish spring night, high on pheromones and – predictably – confused.